HB 1170 revise certain provisions regarding conflicts of interest for ...
State of South Dakota
|
NINETY-SECOND SESSION
LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY, 2017
|
463Y0542
|
SENATE LOCAL GOVERNMENT
ENGROSSED NO. HB 1170 - 3/1/2017
|
Introduced by: Representatives Mickelson, Haggar, Holmes, Johns, Lust, Peterson (Kent),
Qualm, Rhoden, Ring, Schoenfish, Stevens, Tieszen, and Tulson and
Senators Curd, Bolin, Cronin, Frerichs, Greenfield (Brock), Maher, Monroe,
Otten (Ernie), Peters, Rusch, and Sutton
|
FOR AN ACT ENTITLED, An Act to revise certain provisions regarding conflicts of interest
for authority, board, or commission members.
BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA:
Section 1. That chapter 3-23 be amended by adding a NEW SECTION to read:
Terms used in this chapter mean:
(1) "Board member," an elected or appointed member of the governing board;
(2) "Cooperative education service unit," a legal entity created pursuant to §§ 13-5-31
through 13-5-33, inclusive, including subcontractors, agents or assigns of the
cooperative education service unit;
(3) "Disgorgement," the act of giving up on demand or by legal compulsion something
that was obtained by illegal or unethical acts;
(4) "Education service agency," an agency created pursuant to § 13-3-76;
(5) "Local service agency," an entity created pursuant to § 13-15A-1; and
(6) "School district," a school district as defined in § 13-5-1.
Section 2. That § 3-23-1 be amended to read:
3-23-1. No elected or appointed member of a state authority, board, or commission may
have an interest in any contract or derive a direct benefit from any contract with the state which
is within the jurisdiction or relates to the subject matter of the state authority, board or
commission or with a political subdivision of the state if the political subdivision administers
or executes similar subject matter programs as the state authority, board or commission, nor may
the member have an interest in any contract or derive a direct benefit from any contract for one
year after the end of the member's term on the authority, board, or commission except as
provided in §§ 3-23-3 and 3-23-4:
(1) With the state agency to which the authority, board, or commission is attached for
reporting or oversight purposes that requires the expenditure of government funds;
(2) With the state that requires the approval of the authority, board, or commission and
the expenditure of government funds; or
(3) With a political subdivision of the state if the political subdivision approves the
contract and is under the regulatory oversight of the authority, board, or commission,
or the agency to which the authority, board, or commission is attached for reporting
or oversight purposes.
No elected or appointed member of a state authority, board, or commission may derive a
direct benefit from any contract as provided under this section for one year after the end of the
member's term on the authority, board, or commission, except as provided in § 3-23-3 or 3-23-4.
Section 3. That § 3-23-2 be amended to read:
3-23-2. An elected or appointed member of
an a state authority, board, or commission
derives a direct benefit from a contract if the
state authority, board, or commission member, the
authority, board, or commission member's spouse, or any other persons the authority, board, or
commission person with whom the member lives with and or commingles assets:
(1) Is a party to or intended beneficiary of the contract;
(2) Has more than a five percent ownership or other interest in an entity that is a party
to the contract;
(2) Derives income, compensation, or commission directly from the contract or from the
entity that is a party to the contract;
(3) Acquires property under the contract; or
(4) Serves on the board of directors of an entity that derives income or commission
directly from the contract or acquires property under the contract.
An authority, board, or commission member does not derive a direct benefit from a contract
based solely on the value associated with the authority, board, or commission member's
investments or holdings, or the investments or holdings of other persons the authority, board,
or commission member lives with and commingles assets. A member of an authority, board, or
commission does not have an interest in a contract nor does the member receive a direct benefit
by participating in a vote or a decision where the member's only interest is the effect of an act
of general application Will receive from the contracting party compensation, commission,
promotion, or other monetary benefit that is directly attributable to the contract.
Section 4. That chapter 3-23 be amended by adding a NEW SECTION to read:
An elected or appointed member of a state authority, board, or commission has an interest
in a contract if the member, the member's spouse, or any other person with whom the member
lives or commingles assets:
(1) Is employed by a party to the contract; or
(2) Receives more than nominal compensation or reimbursement for actual expenses for
serving on the board of directors of an entity that derives income or commission
directly from the contract or acquires property under the contract.
Section 5. That chapter 3-23 be amended by adding a NEW SECTION to read:
A state authority, board, or commission member does not derive a direct benefit from or
have an interest in a contract:
(1) Based solely on the value associated with the member's publicly-traded investments
or holdings, or the investments or holdings of any other person with whom the
member lives or commingles assets;
(2) By participating in a vote or a decision in which the member's only interest arises
from an act of general application;
(3) If the member is a state employee and is authorized to enter into the contract pursuant
to §§ 5-18A-17 through 5-18A-17.6, inclusive;
(4) If the contract is for the sale of goods, or for maintenance or repair services, in the
regular course of business at or below a price offered to all customers;
(5) If the contract is subject to a public bidding process; or
(6) If the contract is for the deposit of public funds in a financial institution as otherwise
authorized by law.
Section 6. That § 3-23-3 be amended to read:
3-23-3. Any elected or appointed state authority, board, or commission may authorize an
authority, board, or commission member to have an interest in a contract or to derive a direct
benefit from a contract if:
(1) The authority, board, or commission member has provided full written disclosure to
the authority, board, or commission, including:
(a) All parties to the contract;
(b) The member's role in the contract;
(c) The purpose and objective of the contract;
(d) The consideration or benefit conferred or agreed to be conferred upon each
party; and
(e) The duration of the contract;
(2) The authority, board, or commission has reviewed the essential terms of the
transaction or contract and the authority, board, or commission member's role in the
contract or transaction finds that the terms of the contract are fair, reasonable, and not
contrary to the public interest; and
(3) The transaction and the terms of the contract are fair, reasonable, and not contrary to
the public interest authorization is a public record included in the official minutes of
the authority, board, or commission, that shall be filed with the auditor-general and
attorney general.
No member of a state authority, board, or commission may participate in or vote upon a
decision of the state authority, board, or commission relating to a matter in which the member
has an interest or derives a direct benefit.
The authorization shall be in writing. Any authorization given pursuant to this section is a
public record. Each authorization shall be filed with the auditor-general.The auditor-general
shall compile the authorizations and present them annually for review by the Government
Operations and Audit Committee. A member
of an authority, board, or commission may comply
with this section if: the authority, board, or commission puts on its regular meeting agenda an
inquiry for conflicts disclosure prior to the consideration of any substantive matters; the member
publicly discloses his or her interest in a contract, direct benefits, or other conflict with any
matter on the agenda; the member is excused from discussion and consideration of the matter;
the board determines the matter underlying the conflict is fair, reasonable, and not contrary to
the public interest; and the disclosure is included in the minutes which are publicly available
who requests an authorization under this section shall make the request prior to entering into any
contract that requires disclosure or within forty-five days after entering into the contract. Once
disclosed and authorized by the governing board, no further disclosure or authorization is
required unless the contract extends into consecutive fiscal years. A contract that extends into
consecutive fiscal years requires an annual disclosure but no new authorization is required. If
the authority, board, or commission rejects the request for authorization made by the member,
the contract is voidable and subject to disgorgement pursuant to § 3-23-5, or the member may
resign from the authority, board, or commission. No member of a state authority, board, or
commission may participate in or vote upon a decision of the state authority, board, or
commission relating to a matter in which the member derives a direct benefit.
Section 7. That chapter 3-23 be amended by adding a NEW SECTION to read:
Any elected or appointed state authority, board, or commission member may have an interest
in a contract if:
(1) The member, upon learning of the interest subject to the provisions of this chapter
or a transaction that may create an interest subject to the provisions of this chapter
discloses the interest no later than the first meeting of the authority, board, or
commission held after the first day of July of each year;
(2) The authority, board, or commission is notified of the contract and the member's role
in the contract;
(3) The terms of the contract do not violate any other provision of law; and
(4) The disclosure is included in the minutes that are publicly available and are filed with
the auditor-general and attorney general.
Each member shall receive a form, developed by the attorney general, for the purpose of
annual disclosure of any interest and direct benefit covered by the provisions of this Act. In
addition to any interest in a contract and direct benefit covered by the provisions of this Act, the
member shall also disclose at least annually any ownership interest of five percent or greater in
any entity that receives grant money from the state, either directly or by a pass-through grant,
or that contracts with the state or any political subdivision for services. An authority, board, or
commission member who has an interest in a contract pursuant to this section shall disclose the
existence of a contract in which the member has an interest but for which authorization by the
authority, board, or commission is not required for the person to have an interest in the contract.
The auditor-general shall compile and present any disclosure annually for review by the
Department of Legislative Audit and the Government Operations and Audit Committee.
Section 8. That § 3-23-4 be amended to read:
3-23-4. Within the one-year period prohibiting any contract with an elected or appointed
authority, board, or commission member, the authority, board, or commission may approve a
former authority, board, or commission member to contract with the elected or appointed
authority, board, or commission if the authority, board, or commission determines that the
transaction and the terms of the contract are fair, reasonable, and are in the best interests of the
public. The authorization shall be in writing.
Any approval given pursuant to this section
shall be included in the official minutes of the
authority, board, or commission and is a public record.
Each approval The minutes including
the approval shall be filed with the auditor-general
and attorney general. The auditor-general
shall compile
the approvals and present
them any approval annually for review by the
Government Operations and Audit Committee.
Section 9. That § 3-23-5 be amended to read:
3-23-5. Any elected or appointed
state authority, board, or commission member who
knowingly violates §§ 3-23-1 to 3-23-4, inclusive, shall be removed from the authority, board,
or commission and is guilty of a Class 1 misdemeanor.
Any person who knowingly violates
§§ 3-23-1 to 3-23-4, inclusive, and is also guilty of theft under chapter 22-30A, shall be
penalized at the next greater class of penalty prescribed by chapters 22-6 and 22-30A. No
authority, board, or commission member who has submitted a good faith request for
authorization pursuant to section 6 of this Act may be convicted of a crime under this chapter.
Any benefit to the authority, board, or commission member in violation of §§ 3-23-1 and 3-23-2
is subject to
forfeiture disgorgement and any contract made in violation of this chapter is
voidable by the authority, board, or commission.
Section 10. That § 3-23-6 be amended to read:
3-23-6. No board member,
fiscal agent, officer, or executive business manager, chief
financial officer, superintendent, chief executive officer, or other person with the authority to
enter into a contract or spend money in an amount greater than five thousand dollars of a local
service agency, school district, cooperative education service unit, education service agency,
nonprofit education service agency, or jointly governed education service entity that receives
money from or through the state may have an interest in a contract nor receive a direct benefit
from a contract
that in amount greater than five thousand dollars or multiple contracts in an
amount greater than five thousand dollars with the same party within a twelve-month period to
which the local service agency, school district, cooperative education service unit,
or education
service agency
, nonprofit education service agency, or jointly governed education service entity
is a party
to the contract except as provided in § 3-23-8.
Section 11. That § 3-23-7 be amended to read:
3-23-7. A person described in § 3-23-6 derives a direct benefit from a contract if the person,
the person's spouse, or any other persons person with whom the person lives with and
commingles assets:
(1) Is a party to or intended beneficiary of any contract held by the local service agency,
school district, cooperative education service unit, or education service agency;
(2) Has more than a five percent ownership or other interest in an entity that is a party
to the any contract held by the local service agency, school district, cooperative
education service unit, or education service agency;
(2) Derives income, compensation, or commission directly from the contract or from the
entity that is a party to the contract;
(3) Acquires property under the contract; or
(4) Serves on the board of directors of an entity that derives income directly from the
contract or acquires property under the contract Will receive compensation,
commission, promotion, or other monetary benefit directly attributable to any
contract with the local service agency, school district, cooperative education service
unit, or education service agency.
A person does not derive a direct benefit from a contract based solely on the value
associated with the person's investments or holdings, or the investments or holdings of other
persons the state officer or employee lives with and commingles assets.
Section 12. That chapter 3-23 be amended by adding a NEW SECTION to read:
A person described in § 3-23-6 has an interest in a contract if the person, the person's
spouse, or any other person with whom the person lives and commingles assets:
(1) Is employed by a party to any contract with the local service agency, school district,
cooperative education service unit, or education service agency; or
(2) Receives more than nominal compensation or reimbursement for actual expenses for
serving on the board of directors of an entity that derives income or commission
directly from the contract or acquires property under the contract.
Section 13. That chapter 3-23 be amended by adding a NEW SECTION to read:
A person described in § 3-23-6 does not derive a direct benefit from or have an interest in
a contract:
(1) Based solely on the value associated with the person's publicly-traded investments
or holdings, or the investments or holdings of any other person with whom the board
member, business manager, chief financial officer, superintendent, or chief executive
officer lives or commingles assets;
(2) By participating in a vote or a decision in which the person's only interest arises from
an act of general application;
(3) Based on the person receiving income as an employee or independent contractor of
a party with whom the local service agency, school district, cooperative education
service unit, or education service agency has a contract, unless the person receives
compensation or a promotion directly attributable to the contract, or unless the person
is employed by the party as a board member, executive officer, or other person
working for the party in an area related to the contract;
(4) If the contract is for the sale of goods or services, or for maintenance or repair
services, in the regular course of business at a price at or below a price offered to all
customers;
(5) If the contract is subject to a public bidding process;
(6) If the contract is with the official depository as set forth in § 6-1-3;
(7) Based solely on the person receiving nominal income or compensation, a per diem
authorized by law or reimbursement for actual expenses incurred;
(8) If the contract or multiple contracts with the same party within a twelve-month period
with whom the local service agency, school district, cooperative education service
unit, or education service agency contracts in an amount less than five thousand
dollars.
Section 14. That § 3-23-8 be amended to read:
3-23-8. A local service agency, school district, cooperative education service unit, or
education service agency, nonprofit education service agency, or jointly governed education
service entity may authorize a board member, fiscal agent, officer, or executive person described
in § 3-23-6 to have an interest in a contract or derive a direct benefit from a contract if:
(1) The person has provided full written disclosure to the agency, district, or unit
governing board of all parties to the contract, the person's role in the contract, the
purpose or objective of the contract, the consideration or benefit conferred or agreed
to be conferred upon each party, and the duration of the contract;
(2) The governing board has reviewed the essential terms of the transaction or contract
and the person's role in the contract or transaction; and
(3) The transaction or finds that the terms of the contract are fair, reasonable, and not
contrary to the public interest; and
(3) Any request for authorization or governing board action are public records. The
official minutes of the governing board shall include any governing board action on
each request for authorization and shall be filed with the auditor-general and attorney
general.
No member of a local service agency, school district, cooperative education service unit,
education service agency, nonprofit education service agency, or jointly governed education
service entity may participate in or vote upon a decision of a local service agency, school
district, cooperative education service unit, education service agency, nonprofit education
service agency, or jointly governed education service entity relating to a matter in which the
member has an interest or derives a direct benefit.
The authorization shall be in writing. Any authorization given pursuant to this section is a
public record. Each authorization shall be filed with the auditor-general. The auditor-general
shall compile the authorizations and present them annually for review by the Government
Operations and Audit Committee. A board member, fiscal agent, officer, or executive of a local
service agency, school district, cooperative education service unit, education service agency,
nonprofit education service agency, or jointly governed education service entity may comply
with this section if: the local service agency, school district, cooperative education service unit,
education service agency, nonprofit education service agency, or jointly governed education
service entity puts on its regular meeting agenda an inquiry for conflicts disclosure prior to the
consideration of any substantive matters; the person subject to this chapter publicly discloses
his or her interest in a contract, direct benefit, or other conflict with any matter on the agenda;
the person is excused from discussion and consideration of such matters; the board determines
the matter underlying the conflict is fair, reasonable, and not contrary to the public interest; and
the disclosure is included in the minutes which are publicly available. A person described in
§ 3-23-6 who has an interest in a contract pursuant to section 12 of this Act shall disclose the
existence of a contract in which the person has an interest and the person's role in the contract
but no governing board authorization is required for the person to have an interest in the
contract. Disclosure shall also be made at the annual reorganization meeting if the contract
extends into consecutive fiscal years. The interest disclosure shall be included in the official
minutes of the governing board.
Any person receiving a direct benefit from a contract and requesting an authorization
pursuant to § 3-23-8 shall make the request prior to entering into any contract that requires
disclosure or within forty-five days after entering into the contract that requires disclosure. Any
authorization by the governing board requires no further disclosure or authorization unless the
contract extends into consecutive fiscal years. If the contract extends into consecutive fiscal
years, disclosure shall be made annually at the annual reorganization meeting but no new
authorization is required. If the entity rejects any request for authorization, the contract is
voidable and subject to disgorgement pursuant to § 3-23-9 or the person may resign from the
local service agency, school district, cooperative education service unit, or education service
agency.
No board member of a local service agency, school district, cooperative education service
unit, or education service agency may participate in or vote upon a decision of a local service
agency, school district, cooperative education service unit, or education service agency relating
to a matter in which the member derives a direct benefit.
Section 15. That chapter 3-23 be amended by adding a NEW SECTION to read:
Each local service agency, school district, cooperative education service unit, or education
service agency shall develop a written conflict of interest policy, including any disclosure and
authorization form that includes the list of any disclosable interest in contracts or direct benefits
covered by this Act.
Section 16. That § 3-23-9 be amended to read:
3-23-9. Any person who knowingly violates §§ 3-23-6 to 3-23-8, inclusive, shall be removed
from office or employment and is guilty of a Class 1 misdemeanor.
Any person who knowingly
violates §§ 3-23-6 to 3-23-8, inclusive, and is also guilty of theft under chapter 22-30A, shall
be penalized at the next greater class of penalty prescribed by chapters 22-6 and 22-30A. No
person described in § 3-23-6 who has submitted a good faith disclosure or request for
authorization pursuant to section 14 of this Act may be convicted of a crime under this chapter.
Any benefit to a person derived from the person's knowing violation of §§ 3-23-6 to 3-23-8,
inclusive, is subject to forfeiture disgorgement. Any contract made in violation of §§ 3-23-6 to
3-23-8, inclusive, is voidable by the governing body of the local service agency, school district,
cooperative education service unit, or education service agency, nonprofit education service
agency, or jointly governed education service entity.
Section 17. That § 22-30A-11 be amended to read:
22-30A-11. Any person convicted of theft under § 22-30A-10 for unlawfully obtaining
property of this state, of any of its political subdivisions, or of any agency or fund in which the
state or its people are interested shall, in addition to the punishment prescribed by § 22-30A-17
and chapter 22-6 and that may also be prescribed under § 3-23-5 or 3-23-9, be disqualified from
holding any public office, elective or appointive, under the laws of this state, so long as that
person remains a defaulter to this state or any of its political subdivisions, agencies, or funds.